Garnishee Order vs Judgment Debtor Summons: A Creditor's Guide
Updated: 3 days ago
In the world of judgment debt enforcement, a garnishee order vs judgment debtor summons (JDS) debate is usually about whether to start with a JDS and then a garnishee order or go directly to garnishment.
While less steps are always preferable, the fastest route to recovery isn't always the shortest, and our guide aims to help creditors decide which plan applies to them.
Of course, feel free to skip it and get in touch for a free case assessment.
Otherwise, let’s begin.
What does a JDS do?
A judgment debtor summons compels a judgment debtor to appear in court and disclose their financial position under oath, including information relating to income, assets, bank accounts, business revenue, and liabilities.
With this visibility into the debtor's finances, the creditor is then able to make a more informed decision about whether to proceed with garnishee proceedings.
As valuable as this can be, it comes with two major tradeoffs:
Added cost as a JDS requires a separate application and hearing before taking further enforcement action.
It alerts a debtor their assets are being scrutinised which can risk said assets moved out of the court's jurisdiction.
In contrast, the first step of garnishment is an order nisi that temporarily freezes funds without notifying the debtor beforehand - by the time they know, the funds are already inaccessible until proceedings conclude.
So we don't usually want to use a JDS if you don't have to...but sometimes we have to.
When to start with a JDS
If you approached us for help with a judgment debt, we might recommend a JDS if:
you had practically no information about the debtor’s finances
you are unsure if the debtor actually has money or assets worth pursuing
you suspect the debtor has assets but cannot identify them, or
you want full visibility into the debtor's financial position before taking action
A debtor ignoring a JDS can also open the door to committal proceedings which carries the threat of imprisonment for up to several weeks and, in our experience, is highly effective at making unresponsive debtors suddenly pay up.
That said, as this requires actions outside the creditor’s control, it should not be the main reason for initiating JDS proceedings - but under the right circumstances can used to the creditor's advantage.
On the other hand, if the goal is to garnish their bank account, we may not need a JDS, as some research is often enough to reveal potential garnishee banks.
Identifying debtor bank accounts
Generally, a creditor does not need to know their debtor's bank account number or branch - the courts are usually satisfied with proof that a specific bank manages an account for the judgment debtor and is a potential garnishee.
If your debtor is an individual or business that still actively transacts, there will often be enough public paper trails to identify this, and we've had cases where desktop detective work uncovered three potential garnishee banks that allowed us to go straight to a garnishee order nisi - no JDS needed.
You probably already know where to look, but if not our guide to finding debtor bank accounts covers this in full.
That’s it from us, and we wish you a smooth recovery 🙂
Garnish your debtor’s bank accounts with Rule & Co.
With a decade in legal debt recovery, Rule & Co. has supported creditors through countless garnishee proceedings against debtor bank accounts. We guide you through the process from start to finish, helping you understand your options, navigate the court process, and take necessary steps towards recovering what you are owed.
Comments